Protecting clients from Revenue findings on travel and subsistence: find it before they do

When Revenue questions a client's expenses, the practice is in the room, but the Code is clear that the responsibility stays with the client. What a practice can change is timing: a client who finds and corrects an error before a Level 2 letter pays a fraction of the penalty, or none.

Penalty for a careless error with an unprompted qualifying disclosure (20% without)
3%
Penalty for a careless error with an unprompted qualifying disclosure (20% without)
Code of Practice
The notification that ends the chance of an unprompted disclosure
Level 2
The notification that ends the chance of an unprompted disclosure
Timing
A day, interest on late-paid PAYE, from the 14th of the month
0.0274%
A day, interest on late-paid PAYE, from the 14th of the month
Section 991
Records kept after the end of the tax year
6 years
Records kept after the end of the tax year
TDM 05-01-06 1.3

Checked on 7 November 2026 against Revenue's Code of Practice for Revenue Compliance Interventions (effective 1 May 2022) and Tax and Duty Manuals 05-01-06, 05-02-13, 38-03-33 and 42-04-66.

The short version

Client protection in thirty seconds

When Revenue finds that tax-free travel and subsistence was really pay, the employer owes the PAYE, USC and PRSI that wasn't deducted, with interest at 0.0274% a day,[8][6] and may face a penalty from 3% to 100% of the tax under the 2022 Code of Practice.[4] The best outcome needs an unprompted qualifying disclosure, made before Revenue notifies a Level 2 or Level 3 intervention.[4] A readiness review across your client book finds the errors while that window is open.

The employer pays

Even where the tax wasn't deducted.

Interest every day

0.0274% a day on late PAYE.

Disclose early

3% or 5%, not 20% or 40%, for careless errors.

Level 1 isn't too late

The window closes at a Level 2 letter.

Review the book

Twelve questions per client.

Where claims go wrong

What do the rules catch most often?

Revenue doesn't publish a league table of T&S findings. These are the places where an employer's practice most often departs from its manuals, each with the paragraph that settles it.

The errorWhat the rule saysRevenue
The commute paid, including hybrid office daysHome to the normal place of work is taxable; part-time office means the office is the base05-01-06 2.4; 05-02-13 s.6
Trips from home paid on the full distancePay the shorter of home and office to the destination05-01-06 2.4.3
One rate per km, or Band 2 after 5,500 kmCivil service rates are the ceiling; they run in four bands05-01-06 2.5.2, App. 1
Round sums and car allowances as tax-freeTaxable and subject to PAYE05-01-06 3.3, 3.4
Mileage on a company car, van or fuel cardFlat rates assume the employee bears the cost05-01-06 2.5.2
Day rates with no times, or within 8 km5 hours or more, not within 8 km of home or base05-01-06 4.2.1
Records without reason, km or routeName, date, reason, km, start, destination and finish, basis; six years05-01-06 1.3
€3.20 paid on a day with a travel claimThe €3.20 is pay for that day05-02-13 Ex. 4
Directors approving their own claimsCivil service rates rely on a satisfactory control system05-01-06 2.5.2, 4.6
Paid before reported under ERRReport on or before the payment38-03-33
Tax and Duty Manual references: 05-01-06 travel and subsistence, 05-02-13 remote working, 38-03-33 ERR.
Try it

A readiness review for one client

Twelve questions to put to an employer client. Every yes becomes a finding with the Revenue paragraph and the fix, and you can copy the list straight into your letter.

A T&S readiness review for one client

Answer each question for the client. Every yes becomes a finding with the Revenue paragraph and the fix.

  1. 1Is anyone paid for trips to their normal place of work, including hybrid office days?
  2. 2Are trips that start or end at home paid on the full distance from home?
  3. 3Is mileage paid at one rate per km all year, or Band 2 after 5,500 km?
  4. 4Does anyone get a flat weekly or monthly travel or car allowance treated as tax-free?
  5. 5Is mileage paid for a company car or van, or on top of a fuel card?
  6. 6Are day rates paid without departure and return times, or within 8 km?
  7. 7On long stays, is the normal overnight rate paid past night 14 at one place?
  8. 8Do claims lack the reason, km, or start and destination?
  9. 9Is the €3.20 remote working allowance paid on days with a travel claim?
  10. 10Do directors approve their own claims, or get personal costs through as expenses?
  11. 11Has any tax-free T&S been paid before it was reported under ERR?
  12. 12Is country money paid where the firm provides transport or digs, or alongside mileage?
Findings3 of 12 answered
  1. Pay each person on the four bands from their year-to-date km, split at the band edges.
    Revenue TDM 05-01-06 2.5.2, Appendix 1
  2. Report each payment through ROS on or before the payment date.
    Revenue TDM 38-03-33
References are to Revenue’s Tax and Duty Manuals: 05-01-06 (travel and subsistence), 05-02-13 (remote working) and 38-03-33 (ERR).
What a finding costs

Who pays when expenses turn out to be pay?

The employer, and more if the treatment was knowing. Revenue's PAYE manual draws the line between an innocent mistake and pay deliberately labelled as expenses.

Revenue's manual on section 986A says the employer's obligation to remit the tax "exists even in circumstances where the employer fails to make the necessary deductions". For an innocent mistake, re-grossing doesn't apply: the employer is liable for income tax at the employee's marginal rate, with USC and PRSI.[8]

Where pay is knowingly treated as tax-free, the amount is re-grossed, so the employer pays tax on a larger figure. Revenue's own example is a round-sum car allowance processed "as tax free travel expenses", kept going after a Revenue intervention.[8] Interest runs at 0.0274% a day from the 14th of the month after the tax was due,[6][7] and the Code allows no mitigation of interest.[4]

Then the penalty, which depends on the behaviour and on whether the client disclosed first. That is where a practice makes the biggest difference.

SituationEmployer pays
Innocent mistake, e.g. fares repaid gross in errorTax at the employee's marginal rate, with USC and PRSI, plus interest
Pay knowingly treated as tax-free expensesTax on the re-grossed amount, plus interest and a penalty
Tax and Duty Manual 42-04-66, Examples 3 and 4 (updated October 2026).
Penalties and disclosure

How much does timing change the penalty?

A lot. The same careless error costs 5% of the tax with an unprompted disclosure and 40% with none. The Code's table rewards finding it first.

BehaviourNo disclosurePromptedUnprompted
Careless, without significant consequences20%10%3%
Careless, with significant consequences (shortfall over 15%)40%20%5%
Deliberate100%50%10%
With a qualifying disclosure and full cooperation. Without a disclosure but with full cooperation: 15%, 30% and 75%. Second disclosures within five years cost more. Code sections 2.13, 2.14 and 4.6.2.
Worked example

€10,000.00 of tax found: careless, significant consequences

A client paid staff a flat monthly travel allowance as tax-free for two years, and the tax that should have been deducted is €10,000.00, more than 15% of the PAYE correctly payable for those periods. The tax and the interest are the same in every case. The penalty isn't.

Unprompted qualifying disclosure, full cooperation (5%)
€500.00
Prompted qualifying disclosure, full cooperation (20%)
€2,000.00
No disclosure, full cooperation (30%)
€3,000.00
No disclosure, no full cooperation (40%)
€4,000.00
Unprompted versus nothing€500.00 vs €4,000.00
Penalty percentages from the Code of Practice, section 2.13 and 2.14. Interest at 0.0274% a day is added in all cases.

A qualifying disclosure is a written, signed disclosure of complete information on all matters giving rise to the liability, with a declaration and payment of the tax and interest.[4] It is unprompted if made before Revenue notifies a Level 2 or Level 3 intervention, and prompted if made after a Level 2 notification but before the intervention starts.[4]

Level 1 contacts, such as a request to self-review or a profile interview, are there to support compliance and don't close the unprompted window.[4] A client can ask for up to 60 days to prepare a disclosure, if it says so in writing before the Level 2 letter.[4] A qualifying disclosure also means no publication as a defaulter, and Revenue won't open an investigation with a view to prosecution for that default.[4]

No penalty

When is there no penalty at all?

Three routes in the Code. Interest still applies to all of them.

Self-correction

The client notifies Revenue in writing, with a computation, and pays in full. For PAYE, USC and PRSI, before the income tax or corporation tax filing date, otherwise by 31 October of the following year.[4]

Innocent error

A default that is neither deliberate nor a failure to take reasonable care. Revenue looks at the books and records, the compliance history, materiality and how often it happened.[4]

Technical adjustment

A reasonable different reading of the law, shown to Revenue's satisfaction. Matters "well established in case law and precedent" don't qualify.[4]

The responsibility stays with the clientThe Code says "the taxpayer cannot devolve the responsibility of making a correct return to an agent".[4] A practice can't absorb a client's finding, but it can make sure the client finds it first. Records matter here too: full cooperation includes having all books and records available when an intervention starts.[4]
How Revenue looks

How does Revenue choose who to review?

On risk, from data. And since 2024, ERR gives Revenue every tax-free T&S payment as it is made.

"Revenue selects cases for compliance intervention based on risk", using "an expanding range of advanced analytics and data interrogation processes to all data available, including data returned by third parties", including its REAP risk analysis system and real-time risk analytics for PAYE, alongside a small number of random cases.[4] Levels aren't a sequence: Revenue can start at any level.[4]

ERR means each tax-free travel and subsistence payment is reported per employee, and Revenue "expects that all employers providing reportable benefits submit details of same on or before the provision of the benefit".[3] Revenue didn't seek penalties for ERR non-compliance up to 31 December 2024;[9] we found no similar statement for 2025 or 2026. Budget 2027 announced an option to report later from 1 January 2027; until it is law, report on or before payment.

Risk-based selection

Analytics on all data, third-party data included.

Any level first

A Level 2 audit can come without a Level 1.

ERR data

Every tax-free T&S payment, per employee.

The service

What goes into a review you can bill for?

A fixed-scope check, once a year or before a client's year end, that leaves them with a list of fixes and a decision on anything past.

01The base for each employee

Office, depot or home, and why; hybrid staff on the office.

02A sample of claims

Bands, the lesser of, day and overnight tests, records.

03Allowances and cars

Round sums, car allowances, company cars and fuel cards.

04ERR against payroll

Every tax-free payment reported on or before it was paid.

05Fixes and the past

Change the process now; decide on self-correction or disclosure for earlier years.

Test the client's process against the full compliance checklist, and see ERR as a billable service for packaging it with ERR filing.

In the app

What Expense.ie gives the practice

A free practice dashboard across the clients who use Expense.ie, and the records a review needs.

Every client, read-only

The free practice dashboard shows each linked client's claims and reports, and lets you download their ERR exports. Each client pays its own subscription.

Rules applied as they log

Civil service bands from each person's km, "Departs from home" for the shorter distance, and day and overnight rates from the times entered, so many of the errors above don't arise.

Claim checks

Possible duplicates are flagged, and "Worth a look" notes mark repeat destinations and late entries for the client's approvers.

The audit trail

Who submitted, approved and paid each claim and when, exportable with the claims, plus a year-end summary PDF per employee.

ERR, filed before payment

With a practice linked, the client can choose that you tick claims "filed with Revenue" before they can be paid. ERR filing builds the ROS file and tracks what was filed.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

What does Revenue usually find in travel and subsistence?

Revenue doesn't publish a ranked list, but the rules show where claims go wrong: the commute paid as business travel (including hybrid office days), trips from home paid on the full distance, one mileage rate all year instead of the bands, round-sum and car allowances treated as tax-free, mileage paid for company cars, day rates without times, missing records, the €3.20 remote working allowance on travel days, directors' personal costs, and payments made before they were reported under ERR.

Who pays when tax-free expenses are found to be pay?

The employer. Revenue's manual on section 986A says the employer's obligation to remit the tax exists even where it failed to make the deductions. For a genuine mistake, the employer is liable for tax at the employee's marginal rate, with USC and PRSI. Where pay is knowingly treated as tax-free expenses, such as a round-sum car allowance after Revenue has raised it, the amount is re-grossed, so the employer bears more. Interest at 0.0274% a day and penalties can follow.

What penalty applies to a careless T&S error?

Under the Code of Practice for Revenue Compliance Interventions, careless behaviour without significant consequences carries 20%, or 10% with a prompted and 3% with an unprompted qualifying disclosure. Careless behaviour with significant consequences (the shortfall is more than 15% of the tax correctly payable) carries 40%, or 20% prompted and 5% unprompted. Deliberate behaviour starts at 100%.

Can a client still make an unprompted disclosure after a Level 1 letter?

Yes. Under the Code, the opportunity to make an unprompted qualifying disclosure ends when Revenue issues a notification of a Level 2 or Level 3 intervention. A Level 1 contact, such as a request to self-review or a profile interview, does not end it. After a Level 2 notification, a prompted disclosure can be made until the intervention starts.

Is there a penalty for a genuine mistake?

Not where the Code treats it as an innocent error: a default that is neither deliberate nor due to a failure to take reasonable care can be corrected without a penalty, though interest applies. Revenue looks at the records kept, the compliance history, materiality and frequency. A technical adjustment, such as a reasonable different reading of the law, also carries no penalty but does carry interest.

Can the practice take the blame instead of the client?

No. The Code says the taxpayer cannot devolve the responsibility of making a correct return to an agent. That is why a readiness review is worth doing before Revenue asks: it gives the client the chance to correct or disclose on the best terms.

How does Revenue choose employers to review?

On risk. The Code says Revenue selects cases based on risk indicators, using advanced analytics on all data available, including third-party data, its REAP risk analysis system and real-time risk analytics for PAYE, with a small number of random cases. ERR gives Revenue each tax-free T&S payment as it is made.

Is there still a grace period for ERR?

Revenue said it would not seek penalties for ERR non-compliance up to 31 December 2024. We found no similar statement for 2025 or 2026, and Revenue's current ERR manual says it expects each payment to be reported on or before it is made.
Sources

Where these rules come from

Revenue's Code of Practice, Tax and Duty Manuals, guidance pages and eBriefs.

  1. Tax and Duty Manual Part 05-01-06: Tax treatment of the reimbursement of expenses of travel and subsistence to office holders and employeesRevenue Commissioners (last reviewed September 2026)Chapter 1.3 (records, six years), 2.4 and 2.4.3 (commuting, the lesser of), 2.5.2 (civil service rates and a satisfactory recording and internal control system), 3.3 and 3.4 (round sums, car allowances), 4.2 (day and overnight tests), 4.6 (directors), 4.7 (country money).
  2. Tax and Duty Manual Part 05-02-13: Remote Working ReliefRevenue Commissioners (updated May 2026)Section 6 (hybrid workers: the office is the normal place of work); Example 4 (the €3.20 is pay on a day travel and subsistence is claimed).
  3. Tax and Duty Manual Part 38-03-33: Returns by employers in relation to reportable benefits (Enhanced Reporting Requirements)Revenue Commissioners (reviewed September 2026)Reportable benefits submitted "on or before the provision of the benefit"; section 3 on the purpose of ERR.
  4. Code of Practice for Revenue Compliance InterventionsRevenue Commissioners (effective 1 May 2022)Section 1 (Levels 1 to 3, selection on risk, REAP), 2.2 to 2.4 (self-correction, innocent error, technical adjustment), 2.8 to 2.10 (qualifying disclosures, prompted and unprompted), 2.13 and 2.14 (penalties), 4.6.2 (significant consequences: more than 15%), 4.7.4 (€4,000 per breach for employers).
  5. Code of practice and complianceRevenue Commissioners (published 15 May 2026)Lists the 2022 Code as the current edition.
  6. Paying tax to Revenue (employers)Revenue Commissioners (published 4 September 2026)Interest on late employer payments from the 14th of the month, at 0.0274% for every day late.
  7. Guidelines for charging interest on late paymentRevenue Commissioners, Tax and Duty Manual (July 2018)PAYE/PRSI interest under section 991 TCA 1997 at 0.0274% a day.
  8. Tax and Duty Manual Part 42-04-66: Payment made without deduction of income tax (section 986A)Revenue Commissioners (updated October 2026)The employer must remit the tax even where it didn't deduct it; re-grossing where pay is knowingly treated as tax-free expenses (Example 3, a round-sum car allowance), not for innocent mistakes (Example 4).
  9. eBrief No. 179/24: Enhanced Reporting RequirementsRevenue Commissioners (1 July 2024)No penalties sought for ERR non-compliance from 1 July to 31 December 2024.
  10. Enhanced Reporting Requirements (ERR)Revenue Commissioners (published 22 January 2026)Reported on, or before, the payment date, through ROS.

Checked against these sources on 7 November 2026. This is general information, not tax advice. Penalty and disclosure decisions depend on the facts of each case; take advice on your client's situation.

Expense.ie

Review the whole book from one dashboard

A free practice account, every linked client's claims and ERR exports read-only, and the rules applied at source so there is less to find.

Free for practices. Each client pays its own subscription.